Patent Valuation Opportunities Practice Area

Four Kinds of Patent Value  May 20, 2008 – 01:55 am
book on Patent Valuation:

Patents create value for their owners in a variety of different ways. One of the biggest problems with nearly all patent valuation techniques is a failure to be explicit about what kind of value they are attempting to measure. It is essential to have an accurate model of value types in order to identify the source of the information that is needed, and also to formulate the correct approach for interpreting that information.

The Four Kinds of Patent Value

Patents basically allow the rights holder to pursue legal measures to prevent others from practicing the subject matter. This is the reason why many people are quick to point out that patents are only valuable in the way that they act as a blocking mechanism, and this is certainly true. However, although it is very important, it is not accurate to say that the value of a patent is purely a function of its enforceability. In practice, there are different ways to use patents to create value, and people are getting more creative about it all the time.

I group the major ways patents create private economic value into four dimensions.

  1. Practicing

    The first and most obvious method for realizing economic value from patents is by producing and selling products which embody the patent. This is what is known as “practicing” the patent. Value derives from the producer’s ability to exclude competitors and therefore earn monopoly profits. In practice, this type of value is virtually impossible to measure directly particularly because it is nearly impossible to determine exactly how much value is attributable to the patent’s exclusionary rights versus all other factors such as superior design, branding, timing, market power, other intellectual property, and existing manufacturing efficiencies. Another problem is that the value that a company may ascribe to a patent in this context will not normally be the same as the price at which the patent would transact in the market.

Source: Ideanomics

You might also like:

Certified Tax Coach - The Practice You Want Starts Here
Certified Tax Coach - The Practice You Want Starts Here
Columbus Neighborhoods: Olde Towne East
Columbus Neighborhoods: Olde Towne East
Senate Session 2011-10-20 (09:59:45-11:03:49)
Senate Session 2011-10-20 (09:59:45-11:03:49)

A few thoughts

I'm not sure I understand exactly what you're contemplating, but you might find this useful or interesting:
1. People have understood the importance of IP (and patents, specifically) to a company's bottom line for a while. Perhaps the most stark example of this is an investment bank called OceanTomo. Among other IP-centric things, they have a few index funds based on patents. See for an ex... it, but it doesn't really do you any good.
But the guys putting together the portfolio were smart guys, to be sure. They were a bunch of zillionaire Wall Street types with a few fancy patent attorneys thrown in. Although I don't necessarily hold that crowd in high esteem, these guys were smart. So either they're bonkers or I am. And that's enough for me to say that valuation is tricky. :)

Does RIM's Patent Shelf Life Affect its Valuation?  — Trefis
Given RIM's own price per patent valuation at a similar multiple as the Nortel deal, and a 27% premium over the Motorola Mobility deal, Envision IP calculated the remaining patent terms of each patent portfolio to understand one of the reasons why RIM …

6 Ways to Work More Effectively in the US Patent System  — Law.com
Finally, participants recognized the increasingly important relationship between data sets and patent valuation, litigation strategy, risk management, and investment, and therefore found that working with third-party advisory sources could be useful in …

Research In Motion May Burn Close To $1B Cash On BB10  — Seeking Alpha
If you assume that the entire handset business including all inventories is worth $1B, coupled with a decreased network value of $1B, and a very conservative patent valuation of $2B, RIMM is still worth $10. The only scenario that matches a $6 …

John Wiley & Sons Patent Valuation: Improving Decision Making Through Analysis (Wiley Finance (Hardcover) #571) [ PATENT VALUATION: IMPROVING DECISION MAKING THROUGH ANALYSIS (WILEY FINANCE (HARDCOVER) #571) BY Murphy, William J ( Author ) May-08-2012
Book (John Wiley & Sons)

Related posts:

  1. Patents Valuation methods acceptable to IRS
  2. Patent Valuation option
  3. Patent Valuation market approach
  4. Patent Valuation Services India